Both appraisal reports
Each side's number, and the steps each appraiser took to get there.
When the two appraisers in an auto insurance dispute can't agree, an umpire settles the difference. I'm an independent auto appraiser in Atlanta, and as umpire I work for neither the policyholder nor the insurer.
Request received
Thank you. I'll review your details and get back to you within one business day. Need me sooner? Call 404-585-1768.
An appraisal clause umpire is a neutral third person who steps in when the two appraisers on a car insurance claim can't agree on the amount of loss. The umpire works for neither the policyholder nor the insurer, so both sides can trust the result.
It starts with a disagreement over the amount of loss, often a total loss value after a wreck on I-75 or a repair bill after a spring hail storm. One side asks to use the policy's appraisal clause, and each side hires its own appraiser. If those two can't agree, the clause usually calls for an umpire.
The policyholder and the insurer can't agree on the amount of loss.
Each side hires its own appraiser to value the loss and try to agree on a number.
If the two appraisers can't agree, a neutral umpire reviews both positions.
An agreement between the umpire and either appraiser usually sets the amount of loss.
Each appraiser is hired by one side to value the loss and work toward a number with the other appraiser. The umpire comes in only when those two can't agree, and represents no one. The umpire's whole job is to settle the difference based on the evidence.
An appraisal umpire looks at the same evidence both appraisers used. I check how each number was built, find where the two reports split, and decide which proof holds up better on each point. I don't lean toward the policyholder or the insurer.
Each side's number, and the steps each appraiser took to get there.
The comparable vehicles each side used, and whether they really match the one in the claim.
Damage photos, estimates, service records and anything else either side sends.
The items the two appraisers can't agree on, weighed on the evidence alone.
Under most policies, each side pays its own appraiser, and the policyholder and the insurer split the umpire's fee. Terms vary by policy, so read the appraisal clause in yours first. I quote the umpire fee to both sides up front, before any work starts.
Your free case review covers
Once both appraisers agree to use me, I get each side's report and evidence, weigh both by the same standard, and put my number and my reasons in writing. Umpire cases can take longer than a standard report, so I give both sides a timeline up front.
Under many policies, the two appraisers pick the umpire together. Before I say yes, I make sure I haven't worked for either side on the claim.
Both appraisers send me their reports, comparable vehicles, photos and the records behind their numbers.
I check each number the same way and focus on the items where the two reports split.
I write down my number and the reasons for it. An agreement between me and either appraiser usually sets the amount of loss.
I would. I'm Taha Hamed, owner of TBM Auto Appraiser, and I handle every umpire case myself, with more than 500 appraisals behind me. As umpire, I don't represent the policyholder or the insurer, and I won't take the role on a claim where I've worked for either side.
Under most appraisal clauses, an agreement between the umpire and either appraiser sets the amount of loss. Whether that result can be challenged, and how, depends on your policy and the law. Terms vary by policy, so if that question matters in your case, confirm with your attorney.
An umpire only fits once both sides have appraisers and they're stuck. If you still need someone to value the loss for your side, or you only want the insurer's report checked, one of these is a better place to start.