A buyer's guide for drivers with a total loss, diminished value or appraisal clause claim. I compared 15 appraisal companies on the same six factors, and I show my work.
Written by Taha Hamed, owner of TBM Auto AppraiserPublished · Updated
At a glance
At a glance: This is a TBM Auto Appraiser-authored ranking of the car and vehicle appraiser companies that drivers and fleet operators should consider in 2026. TBM Auto Appraiser is on this list at number one. I disclose my methodology below so you can re-rank by the criteria that matter to you. Every company is scored against the same six factors: claim focus, credentials, report strength, price and guarantee, direct access to the appraiser, and reviews. Every fact about another company comes from its own website, checked October 16, 2026.
Key takeaways
This list is written by a working appraiser. Many "best appraiser" pages come from sites that sell leads or reports and never say who wrote them. I sign my name to this one, and I say where my own company falls short.
The ranking is weighted, not a popularity contest. Claim focus counts the most, at 25%. Reviews count the least, at 10%, because review counts are easy to pad and hard to check.
I looked at more than 30 companies and kept 15. I cut lead sites with no named appraiser, firms that mostly work for insurance companies, and sites I couldn't load.
Most posted prices land between $250 and $500. Diminished value reports run about $250 to $475. Appraisal clause work runs about $295 to $495, plus your half of an umpire fee if you need one.
A money-back guarantee is only as good as its fine print. Some refund you if you don't recover the fee. Others require a small claims court award first, or leave out whole states.
Local and national firms fit different cases. A national desk report is fast and cheap. A local appraiser knows your market and can look at your car.
The cheapest report can cost you the most. A thin report that an adjuster waves away costs you the fee and the money you never recovered.
A note before the list
I'm an independent appraiser in Metro Atlanta. Most of my work is total loss and diminished value claims. Drivers often ask me, "Who else should I call?" This page is my honest answer.
"Car appraisal" covers a lot of different jobs. Someone who values a classic car for an agreed value policy does very different work from someone fighting a low total loss offer. This list is about appraisers who work for drivers on insurance claims: total loss, diminished value and the appraisal clause. That's where the wrong pick costs the most money.
To make the list, a company had to name who it is, explain what it does and work for drivers, not insurers. I cut lead sites with no named appraiser or address, firms that mostly take work from insurance companies, and one site that blocked my visit. I work in Georgia, so you'll see the Georgia firms drivers here ask me about, plus national firms that take cases anywhere.
My disclosure: I own TBM Auto Appraiser, and I ranked it first. You should know that before you read another word. I wrote down the six factors before I scored anyone, and I used the same factors for every company. Where TBM loses on a factor, I say so.
One more thing. Licensing rules change from state to state. Some states license damage appraisers and some don't. I list the licenses each company claims on its own site, but I didn't check them against state records. You can, and you should.
The order below is on purpose.
How I ranked these companies
I scored every company against the same six factors and weighted them by how much each one moves your final number. Here's what each factor means and what I looked for.
Factor
Weight
What I looked for
Claim focus
25%
Does the company center on total loss, diminished value and appraisal clause work for drivers? Or is it one service out of forty?
Credentials and repair background
20%
A named appraiser, state licenses, I-CAR or ASE training, and real time spent in collision repair or buying cars.
Report strength
15%
VIN-level options, local comparable cars, a look at the repair, and a report that holds up with an adjuster, an umpire or a judge.
Price and guarantee
15%
A price you know before work starts, and refund terms a normal person can read and actually meet.
Direct access to the appraiser
15%
Do you talk to the person who writes your report, or to a call center?
Reviews and accountability
10%
Google and BBB standing, a real address and an owner who signs their name.
A note on the weights: Reviews get the lowest weight on purpose. They matter, but they're easy to pad and they say little about whether a report holds up. Re-weight to fit your case. If you have a rare or classic car, give credentials more weight. If you live far from Georgia, weigh price and turnaround more and local access less.
A car appraiser puts a dollar value on a vehicle and backs it up in writing. For an insurance claim, that means finding what your car was worth before a crash, or how much value it lost after repairs. An independent appraiser works for you, not the insurance company.
When your car is totaled or damaged, the insurance company already has a number. It usually comes from a valuation report made by a company the insurer pays. An independent appraisal is different in three ways:
Who it works for. The insurer's report is built for the insurer. An independent appraiser is hired by you and owes you an honest number, even when it isn't the number you hoped for.
What it checks. A good appraiser starts with your VIN, so every option and package counts. They use comparable cars from your local market, look at condition and mileage, and check the repair if your car was fixed.
What it's for. The report is your evidence. You use it to push back on a low offer, to file a diminished value claim, or to invoke the appraisal clause in your policy.
Car appraisers do other jobs too, like valuing classic cars, estates, divorces and donated vehicles. This guide focuses on insurance claims because that's where an appraisal most often pays for itself. To see how it plays out on a totaled car, read how a total loss appraisal works.
How much does a car appraisal cost in 2026?
Most posted prices for insurance claim appraisals fall between $250 and $500 in 2026. Diminished value reports run about $250 to $475. Total loss and appraisal clause work runs about $275 to $495. If you need an umpire, plan on about $500 more, usually split with the insurer.
What moves the price. A desk report built from photos and your repair estimate costs less than one with an in-person inspection. Diminished Value of Georgia, for example, lists $275 for a desk appraisal and $425 for a field appraisal. Exotic and high-end cars often cost more. Court testimony and depositions are almost always billed on top.
Flat fee or a share of your money. Most firms on this list charge a flat fee. A few take a percentage of what they recover for you, or mix the two. A percentage can look cheap up front and cost far more on a big claim, so always ask which one you're signing up for.
The umpire. Under the appraisal clause, you and the insurer each pay your own appraiser. If the two appraisers can't agree, an umpire decides, and most policies split the umpire's fee equally. Published umpire fees run about $500 total. Check your policy, since wording varies.
What I charge. I don't post a price list, because cases differ. The case review is free, and I tell you the price before any work starts. One client put it this way in her Google review: "I paid $349 and got the $4800 I deserved back on my car." Your price depends on your case.
Before you hire anyone, ask: "What will this cost me in total, including any inspection, umpire fee or share of my settlement?" A straight answer is a good sign.
Do it yourself, hire an appraiser or hire a lawyer
Doing it yourself works best when the gap is small, a few hundred dollars, and you can find a handful of matching cars for sale near you. Ask the adjuster for the valuation report, mark the mistakes and send your own listings.
An independent appraiser works best when the gap is $1,000 or more, the insurer's report has clear errors, you want to claim diminished value, or you plan to use the appraisal clause. A written report from a credentialed appraiser carries more weight than a stack of listings.
A lawyer works best when someone was hurt, the insurer won't respond, or the claim is headed to court. Many lawyers hire an appraiser for the car part of the case anyway.
Most drivers do a mix. They get the report first, push back with it themselves, and bring in a lawyer only if that fails. I can't give legal advice, but I'll tell you on the free case review if your case looks like it needs one.
The 15 best car appraisal companies, reviewed
Facts about each company come from its own website, checked October 16, 2026. Prices and terms change, so confirm with the company before you hire. Screenshots show each homepage as I saw it that day.
The TBM Auto Appraiser homepage, captured October 16, 2026, as TBM Appraisals.
Best for
Total loss and diminished value claims in Metro Atlanta and across Georgia
Based in
Metro Atlanta, Georgia
Experience
In the car business since 2021, from dealer buying to collision estimating. 500+ appraisals completed.
Credentials
Licensed Motor-Vehicle Damage Appraiser (Lic. #22368340), I-CAR Platinum, BBB Accredited Business with an A+ rating
Price
Free case review. You get the price before any work starts, backed by a 100% money-back guarantee.
TBM Auto Appraiser is my company. I focus on two claims, total loss and diminished value, and the appraisal clause when an insurer won't budge. I write every report myself, and I'm the person you talk to from the first call to the final number. Drivers I've worked with have recovered more than $2.5 million.
Why I rank TBM Auto Appraiser here
Claim focus. Nearly all of my work is total loss and diminished value claims for drivers. That's the factor with the most weight, and it's where I spend my days.
Direct access. You never get passed to a call center or a junior appraiser. You can call me directly, and I explain every number in your report.
A guarantee you can read in one breath. If I don't help you recover enough extra money to cover the appraisal fee, I refund 100% of it. It applies to every insurance claim I take.
Repair and market background. I bought cars for a dealer, then worked as a collision estimator. That's why I check the repair, not only the price of comparable cars.
Where TBM would lose this scoring exercise
Size. I'm one appraiser. A national firm can take a case in Ohio tomorrow. I mostly work in Georgia.
A posted price list. I quote each case after a free review instead of posting prices. Firms like Premier DV and DVCHECK post theirs, and that's easier to shop.
Review count. Wreck Check Atlanta and Expert Asset Protection show hundreds of reviews on their sites. I have fewer.
Courtroom time. Several firms on this list have years of expert witness work. If your case is headed to trial, give that real weight.
I was prepared to accept the insurance company's original offer, but TBM Appraisals assured me that they could help me obtain more and offered a money-back guarantee, so I had nothing to lose. They ultimately helped me recover approximately $3,000 more than the original offer.
Delroy C., Google review
What clients get
A free case review with an honest answer. If an appraisal won't help, I'll say so.
The price before any work starts.
A report built from your VIN, your options and comparable cars from your local market.
If you're in Georgia and fighting a total loss offer or a diminished value claim, start with a free case review. You'll know within one business day if I can help.
The Wreck Check Atlanta homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Diminished value and post-repair inspections from a long-time collision pro
Based in
Alpharetta, GA, with listed locations in Atlanta, Cumming, Milton, Norcross and Kennesaw
Experience
Founded in 2017. Owner R.J. Sweeney lists 29+ years in collision repair.
Credentials
Per its site: licensed in Georgia, North Carolina and South Carolina, ASE Certified Estimator, I-CAR Platinum, BBB Accredited
Published price
$475 for a diminished value or total loss appraisal
R.J. Sweeney managed collision repair centers before he started Wreck Check, and it shows. The site leans hard on improper repairs and post-repair inspections, a step a lot of diminished value reports skip. It also covers the appraisal clause, umpire work, lemon law and dealer fraud inspections, and it offers help in Spanish.
Its site says it has helped Georgia drivers with over 2,000 diminished value and total loss claims, and it shows 650+ five-star reviews.
What I found: Of every firm on this list, Wreck Check does the work closest to mine, with more years behind it. The price is posted up front, which makes it easy to compare.
Skip if you want a simple guarantee. The refund only applies if your final settlement is less than the fee, and the terms ask you to pursue the claim “including legal action if we recommend it.” Leased cars and cars with any prior damage don't qualify.
The Expert Asset Protection homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Georgia diminished value and total loss claims that may end up in court
Based in
Griffin, GA, serving all of Georgia
Experience
Started in 2013, per its site. Founded by Doug and Angela Lawrence.
Credentials
Per its site: licensed public adjusters and I-CAR Platinum certified appraisers (no license numbers listed)
Published price
Not posted. The consultation and case review are free.
Expert Asset Protection is one of the bigger names in Georgia diminished value. Its site cites hundreds of expert court testimonies in Georgia and thousands of total loss appraisals. The team are licensed public adjusters, so they can take on more of the back-and-forth with the insurer than an appraiser alone.
Its guarantee reads: “If you cannot at least double your investment with us based on our analysis, we offer a money-back guarantee.”
What I found: A deep court record and a clear Georgia focus. If your claim looks headed to a judge, that experience counts.
Skip if you want to see a price before you call, or you'd rather work one-on-one with a single appraiser than with a larger team.
The Diminished Value of Georgia homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Posted flat prices and the widest menu of services
Based in
Atlanta, GA, serving the whole state
Experience
Since 2009, per its site. Led by Tony Rached, who says he has appraised over 10,000 vehicles.
Credentials
Per its site: licensed appraisers, USPAP-compliant reports, BBB A+ badge
Published price
$275 desk appraisal, $425 field appraisal (plus $100 for premium vehicles), hourly rates for claim settlement help
Diminished Value of Georgia has the longest service menu here: diminished value, total loss, loss of use, repair audits, classic cars, RVs, GAP, divorce and estate work, expert testimony and umpire services. Its site also explains Georgia's 17c formula, the method many insurers use to calculate diminished value.
Its refund policy offers “a 100% refund of the appraisal fee if your settlement increase does not at least cover the cost of the appraisal,” as long as you follow its steps, such as sending the report to the insurer within 15 days.
What I found: The clearest price list of the Georgia firms, and a real track record with local media.
Skip if you don't want to track deadlines. The refund has conditions, like forwarding insurer replies within 5 business days. The price page also lists more than one hourly rate, so confirm the price when you order.
Fast desk diminished value reports anywhere in the U.S.
Based in
Oregon, serving all 50 states
Experience
Serving drivers since 1996, per its site
Credentials
Owner Monica Fisher is a licensed auto appraiser and court expert witness, licensed in Oregon and North Carolina (per its site). BBB Accredited.
Published price
Diminished value typically $250 to $350. Other appraisals are quoted.
Autoloss is one of the oldest names in diminished value. Reports are built from your repair order and photos, with no inspection, and usually arrive 24 to 48 hours after it has everything it needs. Its site shows a 4.73 rating from 133 BBB reviews.
Diminished value reports may qualify for a conditional money-back guarantee, with state exclusions.
What I found: A fair price, a long track record and fast turnaround.
Skip if you want someone to look at your car in person, or an appraiser who works your local market every day.
6. Collision Safety Consultants of Central Georgia
The Collision Safety Consultants of Central Georgia homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Repair-quality questions and post-repair inspections
Based in
Augusta, GA, covering the upper half of Georgia, Atlanta included
Experience
Owner David A. Clark, Jr. lists 27 years in the collision and automotive industry.
Credentials
Per its site: I-CAR Platinum and ASE Collision Estimator
Published price
Not posted. The consultation is free.
This firm's strength is the repair itself. It does post-collision repair inspections, pre-purchase inspections and improper-repair reviews, along with diminished value reports, total loss disputes and appraisal clause cases. Clark has led high-volume collision centers and co-hosts a nationally syndicated automotive radio show.
You can call or text 24 hours a day, and office visits are by appointment.
What I found: If you think your car was fixed wrong, this is a strong pick.
Skip if you want a posted price or a money-back guarantee. Neither is on its site.
The Premier DV homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Flat-fee appraisal clause and umpire work
Based in
Salt Lake City, UT, serving clients nationwide
Experience
Founder William Heck lists 15+ years of experience.
Credentials
ASCAA Certified Appraiser and I-CAR Platinum badges on its site
Published price
$299 diminished value report, $449 appraisal clause (flat, no percentage), $499 umpire fee
Premier DV (Premier Diminished Value Specialists) posts simple flat prices for every main service. Most reports go out in 1 to 2 business days. For appraisal clause cases, it negotiates with the insurer's appraiser, and the $449 fee is due once the appraisal award is signed.
Its homepage says: “If we can't support at least $1,000 in additional value, you pay $0.”
What I found: Some of the clearest pricing in the industry.
Skip if you want a local appraiser who can see your car. Also ask which services the $1,000 promise covers before you sign up.
The TotalLoss.com homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Total loss disputes under the appraisal clause
Based in
Southfield, MI, serving clients nationwide
Experience
Founder Peter Malinowski is a former insurance adjuster.
Credentials
Per its site: ASE B6 (Damage Analysis and Estimating), I-CAR Platinum, state appraiser licenses in multiple states, BBB Accredited
Published price
$399 flat for the appraisal clause service. The consultation is free.
TotalLoss.com is built around one job: fighting low total loss offers through the appraisal clause. The process usually takes 1 to 2 weeks. It also handles diminished value and auto finance questions. Its site reports an average increase of $3,495 per client.
A founder who used to work as an insurance adjuster knows how the other side builds its number.
What I found: A focused total loss shop with a flat fee and an insider's view of the claim.
Skip if you want a guarantee. No refund policy is listed, and the site says past outcomes are not a guarantee of future results. Also skip it if your main claim is diminished value.
Flat-fee diminished value with support until the claim settles
Based in
Destin, FL, serving clients nationwide
Experience
Founder Jim Marshall lists 25+ years of experience.
Credentials
Per its site: CPCU, AIC and ASE, state appraiser and adjuster licenses in several states, BBB A+
Published price
$399 for diminished value or total loss (more for high-end and exotic cars)
DVCHECK's packages go past the report. They include a demand letter, appraisal clause representation, negotiating with the other appraiser and help picking an umpire. Phone and email support continues until your claim settles. Most reports take 2 to 4 business days.
Its guarantee refunds 100% of the fee if your diminished value recovery is less than what you paid.
What I found: A lot of support for one flat price.
Skip if you don't want to go to small claims court. The refund requires proof of a small claims filing and award. It also doesn't apply in Massachusetts, Michigan, North Dakota, New York or Tennessee, or to leased cars.
The SecondAppraisal homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Total loss appraisal clause with a minimum-result promise
Based in
Salt Lake City, UT
Experience
Its site cites 35+ years of team experience.
Credentials
COO Jonathon Thomas holds appraiser licenses in Connecticut, North Carolina and South Carolina, plus CPCU and AIDA designations (per its site).
Published price
$495 to act as your appraiser, $199 for a research report (credited toward the $495). The umpire fee is separate.
SecondAppraisal acts as your appointed appraiser when you invoke the appraisal clause on a total loss. Its promise: “At least $1,000 more, or your fee is waived,” measured against the insurer's offer. Its site reports an average recovery of $3,648, labeled as past results, not a promise.
It also runs a separate umpire service.
What I found: A clear minimum-result promise and posted prices.
Skip if your claim is diminished value, since this firm is built for total losses. Also check that it covers your state: the site says both “43+ states” and “Active in 3 states.”
The IAS Claims Network homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
A long-running firm for appraisal clause and diminished value work
Based in
Lake Oswego, OR, serving clients nationwide, with a Georgia page
Experience
Appraisal services since 1975, per its site (Insurance Appraisal Services Inc.)
Credentials
Per its site: a nationally licensed appraisal team, and a licensed adjuster reviews diminished value cases
Published price
Georgia appraisal clause and diminished value reports start at $295.
IAS started as a regional appraisal company in the Pacific Northwest and grew into a national appraisal and claims firm. It handles cars, exotics, semi-trucks, RVs and other equipment. Its Georgia page covers appraisal clause claims, ACV reports and diminished value.
Its Georgia page says: “If we can't negotiate a higher settlement that covers our fee, there's no charge.”
What I found: Decades in business and a low starting price.
Skip if you want a Georgia-based appraiser. Its home base is the Pacific Northwest.
The Auto Appraisal Network homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Classic, custom, estate, divorce and other non-claim appraisals
Based in
Laguna Niguel, CA, with franchise appraisers in about 30 metro areas and states
Experience
Serving clients since 1989, per its site
Credentials
Per its site: members of the National Automotive Appraisers Association and the American Society of Appraisers, USPAP-compliant reports
Published price
Online appraisals start at $345, but they can't be used for insurance claims. In-person fees aren't posted.
Auto Appraisal Network is a franchise network, so a local appraiser comes out to see the car. It covers a wide range: total loss, prior-to-loss and diminished value, plus agreed value, estate, divorce, bankruptcy, pre-purchase inspections, court expert witness work, classics, motorcycles, boats and RVs.
What I found: A good fit when you need a car valued for something other than an insurance fight.
Skip if you need help with the appraisal clause. Its site doesn't mention it, and its online appraisals can't be used for insurance claims.
The SnapClaim homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Quick online diminished value or total loss reports
Based in
New York, NY (mailing address), serving all 50 states
Experience
Not stated on its site
Credentials
“Credentialed professionals,” per its site. No licenses are named.
Published price
$350 flat per vehicle for diminished value or total loss. No share of your payout.
SnapClaim is built for speed. Its free estimate takes about a minute, and the report is ready within one business day. It refunds the report fee if your recovery comes to less than $1,000, as long as you ask within 60 days. A company press release describes its reports as AI-driven.
Its FAQ is clear that it doesn't act as your attorney, adjuster or claims representative.
What I found: Fast, flat-priced and simple.
Skip if you want to know the name and license of the person behind your report.
The Select Auto Appraisals homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Fast diminished value and total loss reports
Based in
Not listed on its site. It shows a 770 local office number and serves drivers nationwide.
Experience
8 years, per its site
Credentials
USPAP-compliant reports by certified appraisers, per its site
Published price
Not posted. Total loss reviews are free.
Select Auto Appraisals handles diminished value and total loss claims, with reports usually done in 1 to 2 business days. Its guarantee: “If you don't recover double the cost of your appraisal report fee, we'll give you your money back.”
What I found: Quick turnaround and a strong-sounding guarantee.
Skip if you want a named appraiser and a street address before you hire. Neither is on its site.
The Auto Damage Experts homepage, captured October 16, 2026.
Best for
Post-repair inspections and repair monitoring
Based in
Beaverton, OR, with a second office in the Tampa area
Experience
Appraisals since 2001 and repair consulting since 1994, per its site
Credentials
BBB Accredited. Per its site, it follows the standards of the Automotive Service Association, CCRE and SCRS.
Published price
Not posted. The consultation is free.
Auto Damage Experts comes from the repair side of the business. It does diminished value, total loss replacement value, pre-repair and post-repair inspections, repair monitoring and evidence preservation, plus IRS, divorce and estate appraisals. Its site notes that appraisal fees may be recoverable as part of your claim.
What I found: Long experience with repair quality, which matters a lot in diminished value.
Skip if you're in Georgia and want local comparable cars. Its local coverage is Oregon and Florida.
What other rankings miss
How to read this list: a ranking can tell you who to call first. It can't tell you whether a company's report will hold up on your claim. Only the report can.
Most rankings compare what's easy to see: prices, star ratings and years in business. Those matter. But three things decide whether an appraisal pays off, and they're harder to judge from the outside.
The report itself. You can't see a report before you buy one. Ask for a sample with the personal details removed. Look for real comparable cars with links or VINs, every adjustment explained, and a clear final number.
Who stays with you. Some firms send a report and they're done. Others stay through the back-and-forth, and through the appraisal clause if it comes to that. Ask before you pay.
Local market knowledge. Car prices differ by city. An appraiser who knows your market finds better comparable cars, and better comparable cars mean a stronger number.
What car appraisers actually do
Total loss valuation. Find what your car was worth the moment before the crash, called actual cash value or ACV, and show why the insurer's number is low. See total loss appraisals.
Diminished value. Measure how much value your car lost because it now has an accident on its record, even after a good repair. See diminished value appraisals.
Repair review. Check whether the repair was done right. A poor repair lowers value even more and can be a safety problem.
Appraisal clause and umpire work. Act as your appraiser in a formal dispute with your insurer, or serve as the neutral umpire when two appraisers can't agree.
Non-claim appraisals. Value a car for a classic car policy, a divorce, an estate, a donation or a purchase.
How to choose a car appraiser
The top deal breaker: an appraiser who won't tell you the full price before they start. Walk away.
1. Who will write my report, and can I talk to them?
You want a named appraiser who will explain the report and answer your adjuster's questions.
Red flag: nobody will give you a name, or every call goes to a different person.
2. How many claims like mine have you handled?
Total loss, diminished value and the appraisal clause are different jobs. Ask about your exact one.
Red flag: the company lists 40 services and none of them stands out.
3. What will this cost me in total?
Ask about inspection fees, rush fees, umpire fees and any share of your settlement.
Red flag: a percentage of your recovery tucked into the contract.
4. What does your guarantee ask of me?
Read the refund terms before you pay. The best ones are short.
Red flag: you only get a refund after you file in court and win.
5. Can I see a sample report?
A strong report lists real comparable cars, explains every adjustment and shows its math.
Red flag: one page with a number and nothing to back it up.
Why the cheapest appraisal can cost you the most
It's tempting to pick the lowest price. On a $250 report versus a $450 one, you save $200. But an adjuster can wave off a thin report in a single email. Then you're out the fee and still stuck with the low offer.
It gets worse in the appraisal clause. If your appraiser can't defend their number, the umpire usually lands closer to the insurer's. On a total loss, that gap is often thousands of dollars.
The math favors a report that gets taken seriously. Pay for the one that holds up, not the one that's cheapest.
Pricing for car appraisal services in 2026
These ranges come from prices that appraisal companies post on their own sites, checked October 16, 2026. Your price depends on your car, your claim and where you live.
Service
Typical price
What's included
Case review or estimate
Free
A first look at your offer and whether a report would help
Diminished value report (desk)
$250 to $400
A report built from your repair estimate and photos
Diminished value report (with inspection)
$425 to $475
Adds an in-person look at the repaired car
Total loss appraisal
$275 to $475
Actual cash value with VIN-level options and comparable cars
Appraisal clause appraiser
$295 to $495 flat
Your appointed appraiser, who works out the number with the insurer's appraiser
Umpire
About $500 total, usually split
A neutral who settles the number if the two appraisers can't agree
Pre-purchase inspection
$210 to $450
A check before you buy. Price depends on the vehicle type.
Classic or collector appraisal
About $150 to $350
Varies a lot by local market and appraiser
Exotic cars, rush jobs, travel and court testimony usually cost extra.
Questions about choosing a car appraiser
What's the difference between a car appraiser and an insurance adjuster?
An adjuster works for the insurance company and handles your claim. An appraiser puts a value on your car. The insurer's valuation comes from a company it pays. An independent appraiser is hired by you, so the report is your evidence when you think the insurer's number is wrong.
How do I know if I need an independent car appraisal?
Get one if your total loss offer looks $1,000 or more below what cars like yours sell for, if the insurer's report has the wrong trim or missing options, or if your car was repaired after a crash that wasn't your fault. A free case review will tell you if it's worth it.
Can I hire an appraiser from another state?
Often, yes. Many appraisers work from photos, the repair estimate and market data. But your car's value depends on your local market, and some states have their own licensing rules. Ask how the appraiser finds comparable cars near you and whether they're allowed to work in your state.
How long does a car appraisal take?
Most reports take 1 to 5 business days once the appraiser has what they need. Appraisal clause cases take longer, often 1 to 3 weeks, because two appraisers have to work out a number. Ask for a timeline before you hire anyone.
Do insurance companies accept independent appraisals?
They don't have to agree with it, but a well-backed report often moves the offer. If your own insurer still won't budge, most policies have an appraisal clause. For a diminished value claim against the other driver's insurer, you may need small claims court or a lawyer.
Who pays for the umpire in the appraisal clause?
Most policies say each side pays its own appraiser and the umpire's fee is split equally between you and the insurer. Published umpire fees run about $500 total. Read the appraisal section of your policy, since the wording varies.
About the author
Taha Hamed owns TBM Auto Appraiser in Metro Atlanta. He's worked in vehicle acquisition and market valuation since 2021, then in collision estimating. Today he's a licensed Motor-Vehicle Damage Appraiser (Lic. #22368340) with I-CAR Platinum recognition, and he focuses on total loss and diminished value claims.
Send me the insurer's offer and your car details. You'll get an honest answer within one business day, even if that answer is to call someone else on this list.